The black speckling along the bottom of a shower tray is the single most common thing I get asked about in London bathrooms, and it is also the thing homeowners most often waste a weekend on. There is a good method and a bad method, and the gap between them is mostly patience rather than product.
There is also a point past which no method works. Knowing where that point sits saves you the weekend.
Why does mould grow in the silicone and not on the tile?
Because silicone gives it something to eat and somewhere to live, and glazed ceramic gives it neither.
Cured sanitary silicone is a soft, slightly porous polymer. It holds a permanent microscopic texture, it stays damp for hours after the tile has dried, and it carries plasticisers and additives that certain moulds are quite happy to metabolise. On top of that sits the real food source: soap scum, skin oils, shampoo residue. A tiled wall in a Catford bathroom sheds that film every time it is wiped. The sealant bead at the bottom holds it.
Add the temperature. London bathrooms in converted flats are often the coldest room in the property, frequently on an external wall, sometimes with no radiator at all beyond a heated towel rail nobody switches on in July. Warm shower air hits a cold surface, condenses, and the last place to dry is the joint between the tray and the wall.
What the black staining is
Hyphae, mostly – the root structure of the fungus, growing down into the polymer rather than sitting on top of it. That single fact determines everything about how you treat it.
Surface mould wipes off with a cloth. Once the hyphae have penetrated, the pigment is inside the material, and no amount of scrubbing reaches it because there is nothing on the surface left to remove. Nine times out of ten, when someone tells me they have scrubbed the sealant raw and the black is still there, this is why.
What removes it, and what only pretends to?
Sodium hypochlorite, given time. Everything else is theatre.
Household thin bleach at roughly one part to four parts water will do it. So will a thick bleach gel, and so will the proprietary mould sprays sold at four times the price, which are largely the same chemistry with a thickener and a fragrance. The active ingredient bleaches the melanin pigment in the fungal structure, which is why the black fades rather than lifts.
What matters is dwell time. A spray applied and rinsed after ten minutes does very little, because the liquid runs off a vertical bead within seconds and evaporates from a horizontal one within minutes. The chemical needs to sit against the silicone for hours to work its way into the polymer.
Vinegar is the one I argue about, and nine times out of ten the argument goes the same way. It kills some surface mould and it does nothing whatsoever for the staining, because acetic acid does not bleach pigment. Bicarbonate of soda is an abrasive, and abrasion on silicone roughens the surface and gives the next colony a better foothold. The two of them together, which is the internet’s favourite bathroom remedy, produce sodium acetate and a fizzing noise.
Hydrogen peroxide at 6% or higher works and is gentler on coloured grout. It is slower.
The poultice method, which is the only one worth doing
Cut a strip of cotton wool or kitchen roll to the length of the bead. Soak it in diluted bleach until it is saturated but not dripping. Press it onto the sealant so it sits in contact along the whole run, then cover the lot with cling film, pressed down at the edges to stop evaporation.
Leave it. Two hours minimum. Overnight for anything heavy, and I have left poultices on for a full working day on a badly gone bead in a Wembley Park flat and come back to sealant that had returned to about ninety per cent white.
Remove, rinse thoroughly with clean water, dry the joint completely.
Ventilate the room while it dwells, keep the door shut on pets, and under no circumstances use a bleach product anywhere near an acidic limescale remover. Chlorine gas is produced by that combination and bathrooms are small rooms. If you have descaled the screen that morning, rinse everything down before you start on the sealant.
When is cleaning it a waste of time?
More often than a cleaning contractor is supposed to say.
Here is my position, and I hold it against most of the industry: if the blackening runs the full length of the bead, or has come back within eight weeks of a proper poultice, you should be cutting it out and replacing it rather than cleaning it. The material has failed. You are treating a symptom in a substrate that has colonies growing inside it and behind it, and every treatment buys less time than the one before.
A tube of sanitary silicone is around £8. A bathroom deep clean where I spend ninety minutes fighting a dead bead costs you considerably more than that and looks worse at the end.
The exception is a bead where the mould is patchy, recent and confined to one section – usually the corner behind the shower mixer where water pools. Poultice that, sort the drying habits, and it will hold for years.
How to tell the bead has gone
Press it with a fingernail. Sound silicone is firm and springs back. Failed silicone feels soft or spongy, sometimes slimy, and if the nail leaves a mark that stays, the polymer has degraded.
Then look at the edges. A hairline dark line where the silicone meets the tile means water has been getting behind it, and whatever is growing back there will re-emerge through the new bead within a season if you do not deal with the moisture path.
How do you replace a bead of silicone properly?
The removal is nine tenths of the job and it is the part people rush.
Score both edges with a sharp blade held flat to the surface, then pull the bead away in one length if you can. Get every trace off – a silicone removal tool or a plastic scraper, then a solvent silicone remover for the last film. New silicone will not bond to old silicone residue, and a bead applied over the ghost of the last one lifts at the edges within months and lets water in immediately.
Then dry it. This is the step that gets skipped. The joint needs to be bone dry before the new sealant goes on, which in a bathroom in a Poplar flat with no window means a fan heater or a hairdryer and then twenty-four hours of not using the shower. Wipe the dry joint with isopropyl alcohol before you start, which removes the residual soap film and kills what is sitting on the surface.
Use a sanitary-grade silicone with a fungicide in it. Fill the bath with water before sealing round a bath, and leave it full until the sealant has skinned, so the joint is sized for the loaded position rather than the empty one – a bath drops several millimetres under a person and a rigid new bead will split on the first use.
The bit that decides how long it lasts
Tooling. One pass with a wetted finger or a proper tool, in one direction, without stopping. A bead that has been gone over four times has air trapped in it and a rippled surface with a hundred small ledges for water to sit in, and it will discolour first along exactly those ridges.
How do you stop it coming back?
Manage the drying time, and nothing else on the list matters as much.
Mould needs the surface to stay wet for hours. Cut that window and the colony cannot establish, whatever is on the walls. Which means: run the extractor fan for fifteen to twenty minutes after the shower, not during it alone – most fans wired to the light switch have a run-on timer that has either been disabled or was never set, and it is worth getting an electrician to check yours. Open the window in an Acton bathroom in January even though it is cold, five minutes will do.
Squeegee the screen and the tray. Ten seconds. This single habit removes more standing water from a bathroom than everything else combined.
Leave the shower door open rather than shut. Keep the room warmer, because a bathroom held at 18 degrees condenses far less than one at 12. And on the joint itself, a quick wipe with a dry cloth along the sealant once a week does more than any monthly deep clean.
Heated towel rails on a summer setting are the cheapest mould prevention in the building, and nine times out of ten the flats I work in have theirs switched off from April to October.
Anti-mould paint and the other half-measures
Mould-resistant emulsion on the ceiling helps in a room that already ventilates properly and does very little in one that does not. Same with the silicone: the fungicide in sanitary grade is a delaying additive with a working life of a few years, and it leaches out faster in a bathroom that stays wet. Dehumidifiers work, though a small desiccant unit run for an hour after the shower is a lot of money and noise for something a squeegee and a fan achieve.
The products are a supplement to drying the room. They are not a replacement for it, and any bathroom where the sealant blackens twice in the same year has a ventilation problem wearing a cleaning problem as a disguise.
The last silicone I replaced was in a Brixton shower room where the tenant had been poulticing the same bead every two months for a year and a half. Took forty minutes to cut out. The wall behind it was black to about two inches up, which she had never seen, and which no bleach in the world was ever going to reach.