Ask a cleaner whether they are insured and you will get a yes. You will get a yes from the good ones, the mediocre ones, and the man who does four flats in Stanmore on a Tuesday with a hoover in the back of a Corsa and no policy whatsoever, because the question is so routine that a truthful answer has stopped occurring to anybody.

The word is close to meaningless on its own. What matters is which cover, at what limit, with what excluded, and whether the thing most likely to go wrong in your house sits inside the policy or outside it. In my experience, it usually sits outside it.

Is a cleaner even required to carry insurance?

No, and this catches people out.

Public liability insurance is not a statutory requirement for a self-employed cleaner in the UK. A sole trader can trade for a decade, clean two hundred London homes, and never buy a policy without breaking any law. It is not a legal requirement for most businesses, unlike employers’ liability, which is legally required once you have employees. So when a cleaner tells you they are fully legal, that statement and the insurance question are answering different things.

Employers’ liability is the one with teeth. The moment a cleaning business takes on anyone – including seasonal staff and subcontractors – employers’ liability becomes a legal requirement, and non-compliance carries a fine of up to around £2,500 per day. That matters to you if you are booking through an agency, because the person standing in your hallway may be an employee of the agency or a self-employed cleaner it merely introduced, and each has a different insurance position. Agencies are rarely eager to clarify which.

The introduction agency dodge

A large slice of the London domestic market runs on introduction. The company takes a fee, matches you with a cleaner, and the contract for the cleaning work sits between you and that individual. The agency’s own insurance covers the agency’s business – its office, its staff, its liability as an introducer. It may not extend to the person cleaning your bathroom.

Ask the question directly: is my cleaner your employee, or are you introducing me to a self-employed person? Then ask who holds the policy that would pay if she puts a hot iron through the runner in the hall. Mind you, the answer arriving slowly is itself an answer.

What does public liability pay for?

Injury to a third party, and damage to your property caused by the cleaner’s work. A ladder through a window at a house in Winchmore Hill, a slip on a wet floor by the postman, a bottle of something caustic knocked into the fabric of a sofa. Standard limits run from £1m up to £5m, and for domestic work in a flat, £1m is plenty – you are unlikely to generate a seven-figure claim with a mop.

Here is the part almost nobody checks. Most standard policies exclude damage to the thing being worked on.

Treatment risk covers damage caused by cleaning solutions or chemicals during the job – bleach discolouring a carpet, a product damaging a surface – and most standard liability policies exclude it, which leaves the cleaner personally liable for the cost. Specialist cleaning policies add it back in alongside damage to property worked on, key loss and employee dishonesty.

Sit with that for a second. The overwhelming majority of domestic cleaning accidents are damage to the surface being cleaned. Someone uses an acidic descaler on a honed limestone worktop in a Fulham kitchen and etches it dull. Someone puts a cream cleaner on a brushed brass tap and takes the lacquer off. Someone leaves a bleach-based product sitting on a coloured grout line in Petts Wood for twenty minutes. Every one of those is a treatment risk claim, and under a bog-standard policy every one of them is refused.

So the certificate your cleaner emailed over is, in the most common failure scenario, decorative. That is my strong view and I am comfortable with how unpopular it makes me among people who sell certificates.

What to read on the schedule

Skip the headline limit. Go to the endorsements and the exclusions and look for two specific phrases: treatment risk, and damage to property in your care, custody or control. Any policy carrying both has been bought by someone who read it. A policy carrying neither was bought at four in the morning for £6 a month to satisfy a client who was never going to check.

Check the excess too. Budget policies that do include treatment risks often carry an excess around £500. If your cleaner would have to find £500 before the insurer pays a penny, small claims will never be made, whatever the paperwork says.

Does the certificate on its own prove anything?

It proves a policy existed on the date printed.

I have been sent screenshots of certificates that expired in 2023. I have seen a certificate for a limited company whose cleaner had left that company eight months earlier and gone independent. I have seen one that covered domestic cleaning only, held by a firm doing end-of-tenancy work with steam machines and industrial degreasers, which is a different trade with a different risk profile and would very likely be a declined claim.

Three things make a certificate useful, and you can check all of them from your phone while the kettle boils. The name on it has to match the person or company invoicing you. The dates have to include today. And the description of business has to match the work being done in your house – policies are rated on the activity described, so a cleaner who describes themselves as domestic only and then takes on commercial or specialist work has a gap.

If you want to be thorough, ring the insurer or the broker named on the document and ask whether the policy number is live. Takes four minutes. Almost nobody does it, which is precisely why the expired-certificate trick keeps working across half of Greater London.

Keys, alarms and the cover people forget

Key cover is not automatically part of public liability – if a cleaner holds your keys, key loss and the associated locksmith and call-out costs need checking specifically. On a flat with a communal fob, a shared entrance and a Banham lock, a lost keyset is not a £15 problem. It is a locksmith, a new cylinder, and possibly a re-fobbing charge from the managing agent that lands at several hundred pounds.

I hold keys for eleven households between Carshalton and Sutton and I pay extra for that cover every year. Mind you, I lost a set exactly once, in 2019, down the side of a car seat, and the client found out because I told her before I found them.

What happens when something gets broken?

The insurance question and the honesty question are separate, and the second one predicts the outcome better.

Most domestic breakages are small. A glass, or a chip out of a mirrored cabinet door in a Bermondsey bathroom. These sit below any sensible policy excess, which means the insurer is irrelevant and the only thing that determines whether you are made whole is whether the cleaner tells you and offers to sort it. A cleaner who leaves the pieces in the bin and says nothing has told you everything you need to know about how the £2,000 claim would go.

For the larger events – water damage from a machine left running, a fall on your stairs – insurance is the whole ballgame. Water is the one to watch in flats. A cleaner who runs a washing machine or a dishwasher and leaves before the cycle ends is exposing you to a leak claim against your downstairs neighbour, and the sums in a converted terrace in Ealing get large fast once you are into other people’s ceilings.

The advice that costs me work

If a cleaner damages something in your home and the value is under a few hundred pounds, your own home contents policy with accidental damage cover will settle it faster and with less friction than pursuing the cleaner’s insurer, and in many cases your insurer will pay and not bother recovering it.

That advice is against my interests to give, because it makes my insurance status less of a selling point than the bloke down the road who has none. I would rather you knew.

How should you handle this at the booking stage?

Ask before the first visit, not after the first breakage. Request the certificate as a document rather than a claim, check the name and dates, and read for the three exclusion phrases. Ask whether the cleaner is employed or self-employed. Ask what happened the last time they broke something, which is a better question than any of the others, and watch how quickly the answer comes.

A cleaner who has been working London homes for a decade has broken things. Anyone claiming otherwise is either new or lying, and I would rather hear about the chipped Belfast sink in Orpington than a spotless record.

Price and cover move together

Cover costs money and the money comes out of the hourly rate. Basic public liability for a cleaner starts at around £5 to £6 a month, with the figure rising once accidental damage, tools and specialist work get added, and a properly endorsed policy with treatment risk and key cover on top lands closer to a few hundred pounds a year. Spread across a round of thirty households, that is small. Spread across a cleaner doing six houses a week cash-in-hand, it is a meaningful chunk of a week’s takings, which is why the cheapest quote in your inbox is often the uninsured one.

Mind you, I have met superb uninsured cleaners and insured ones I would not let past the door. The paperwork tells you about risk transfer. It tells you nothing about whether the skirting boards get done.

Mine is a wine glass in a Winchmore Hill kitchen, September, stem snapped in the drying rack. Cost me £11 to replace and I never mentioned the insurance once.